Halting the senseless civil war against white-collar offenders: “the conduct undermined the integrity of the markets” and other fallacies

Bagaric, Mirko, Du Plessis, Jean and Silver, Jaclyn 2016, Halting the senseless civil war against white-collar offenders: “the conduct undermined the integrity of the markets” and other fallacies, Michigan State law review, no. 4, pp. 1019-1090.

Attached Files
Name Description MIMEType Size Downloads

Title Halting the senseless civil war against white-collar offenders: “the conduct undermined the integrity of the markets” and other fallacies
Author(s) Bagaric, Mirko
Du Plessis, JeanORCID iD for Du Plessis, Jean orcid.org/0000-0001-7192-0080
Silver, Jaclyn
Journal name Michigan State law review
Issue number 4
Start page 1019
End page 1090
Total pages 72
Publisher Michigan State University, College of Law
Place of publication East Lansing, Mich.
Publication date 2016
Summary White-collar offenders understandably attract a significant amount of resentment and animosity. They often make large profits through cheating the financial system. The antipathy the community feels towards these offenders has resulted in increasingly tough sanctions being meted out to them. In the United States, it is not uncommon for white-collar offenders to be sentenced to imprisonment for over a decade. This approach is fundamentally flawed. It is an illustration of collective community venting prevailing over sound evidence-based policy. This Article focuses on white-collar offenders who cheat the stock market. We argue that the reflexive unabated practice of increasingly harsh penalties for offenders who commit insider trading and market manipulation offenses has resulted in the community punishing itself by directing scarce public resources into the prison industry and away from demonstrable social goods in the form of education and health, without any corresponding benefit to the community. The two main reasons for imposing harsh sentences on market cheats are the desire to deter others from committing similar offenses and to maintain the integrity of the markets.In this Article, we demonstrate that these rationales are flawed. The weight of existing empirical data establishes that long prison terms do not deter people from committing similar offenses. We also examine the impact of high profile market offenses on the value of shares. The article contains an empirical analysis regarding whether there is a link between white-collar offenses and the integrity of the markets (which is an assumption made by courts). The study shows that there is no demonstrable link between major stock market crime and a lowering in the value of the market. The value of the stock market does not normally fall in response to high profile financial market offenses. This Article argues that the civil war against white-collar offenders should stop. The humanistic toll on white-collar offenders (as a result of being subjected to disproportionate punishment) and the financial burden on the community stemming from the burgeoning cost of imprisonment have already produced too much self-inflicted harm. Imprisoning fewer white-collar (and other fraud) offenders will assist in ameliorating the incarceration crisis in the United States while at the same time ensuring that proportionate penalties are imposed on such offenders. It will also hopefully provide the impetus for more wide-ranging evidence-based reforms to the sentencing system, which has resulted in more than two million Americans being incarcerated—the highest in history.
Language eng
Field of Research 180109 Corporations and Associations Law
180110 Criminal Law and Procedure
Socio Economic Objective 940404 Law Enforcement
HERDC Research category C1 Refereed article in a scholarly journal
ERA Research output type C Journal article
Copyright notice ©[2016, Michigan State University, College of Law]
Persistent URL http://hdl.handle.net/10536/DRO/DU:30090625

Document type: Journal Article
Collections: Faculty of Business and Law
Connect to link resolver
Unless expressly stated otherwise, the copyright for items in DRO is owned by the author, with all rights reserved.

Version Filter Type
Citation counts: TR Web of Science Citation Count  Cited 0 times in TR Web of Science
Scopus Citation Count Cited 0 times in Scopus
Google Scholar Search Google Scholar
Access Statistics: 473 Abstract Views, 7 File Downloads  -  Detailed Statistics
Created: Wed, 18 Jan 2017, 11:17:19 EST

Every reasonable effort has been made to ensure that permission has been obtained for items included in DRO. If you believe that your rights have been infringed by this repository, please contact drosupport@deakin.edu.au.