hubber-reasoninginscience-2013.pdf (1.63 MB)
Download file

Reasoning in science through representation

Download (1.63 MB)
chapter
posted on 01.02.2013, 00:00 authored by Russell TytlerRussell Tytler, Vaughan PrainVaughan Prain, Peter Hubber, F Haslam
In this chapter we argue that our analysis of student reasoning through constructing representations points to a range of informal and formal reasoning processes. This suggests the need for researchers and teachers to shift from an exclusive focus on formal syllogistic reasoning as the main or only reasoning resource for science learning. First we review the literature to identify how informal reasoning is described, and relates to reasoning through representation, then examine one case of reasoning during a representational challenge, to argue that reasoning should be thought of as deliberative thinking that involves choices, leading to a justifiable claim. Two case studies from RILS units are then used to identify how reasoning through representation can occur at a number of points during a representational challenge, and finally to develop an indicative taxonomy of the different purposes of reasoning as part of the processes of science.

History

Title of book

Constructing Representations to Learn in Science

Chapter number

6

Pagination

83 - 108

Publisher

Sense Publishers

Place of publication

Rotterdam, Netherlands

ISBN-13

9789462092037

Language

eng

Publication classification

B1 Book chapter; B Book chapter

Copyright notice

2013, Sense Publishers

Extent

12

Editor/Contributor(s)

R Tytler, V Prain, P Hubber, B Waldrip

Usage metrics

Read the peer-reviewed publication

Categories

Exports