File(s) under permanent embargo
Assessing the accuracy of Sentinel-2 instantaneous subpixel shorelines using synchronous UAV ground truth surveys
journal contribution
posted on 2022-11-24, 23:56 authored by Nicolas Pucino, DM Kennedy, Mary YoungMary Young, Daniel IerodiaconouDaniel IerodiaconouDue to recent technological advancements in the field of cloud-based satellite remote sensing, the barriers to global analysis ready dataset access and processing have lowered drastically increasing the opportunity for large-scale long-term satellite-derived shoreline monitoring solutions. However, validation studies employing synchronous and independent in-situ instantaneous shorelines at scale are limited. Thanks to a unique dataset of 47 synchronous UAV photogrammetric surveys in 15 coastal locations in Victoria, Australia, over 3 years, we validated Sentinel-2 instantaneous subpixel shorelines extracted using the most common water indices, CoastSat and a tidal-balanced convolutional neural network (Unet+++). We assessed the accuracy of the water level estimation using 9 wave run-up models and wave data sourced from a nearshore wave buoy network, a regional hindcast model and a global altimeter wave dataset. This paper also presents the first validation of Deep Learning-derived shorelines using synchronous independent in-situ data. We found the best overall performance and least threshold-sensitive shoreline extraction approach to be the WI index, whilst NDWI had the poorest performances despite being the most utilized across the literature. We found that the thresholdless Unet+++ solution coupled with an ensemble wave run-up model and the altimeter wave data is an adequate trade-off in terms of accuracy, adaptability and wave data access for global scale shoreline studies. Moreover, we highlighted the very high spatial variability of beach-scale shoreline extraction performances and found that generally, the best SDS extractor only performs best along 30–40% of a coastline. Our results suggest that future satellite-derived shoreline approaches should investigate the relationships between scene-dependent variables and shoreline accuracies in order to better understand the causes of beach-scale performance variations and increase the accuracy of satellite-derived shorelines.
History
Journal
Remote Sensing of EnvironmentVolume
282Article number
13293Pagination
1-19Location
Amsterdam, The NetherlandsPublisher DOI
ISSN
0034-4257eISSN
1879-0704Language
EnglishPublication classification
C1 Refereed article in a scholarly journalPublisher
ElsevierUsage metrics
Categories
Keywords
AccuracyAUSTRALIABEACHESCLASSIFICATIONCOASTLINEDeep learningEnvironmental SciencesEnvironmental Sciences & EcologyEXTRACTIONImaging Science & Photographic TechnologyLife Sciences & BiomedicineMODELSNEURAL-NETWORKSRemote SensingSatelliteScience & TechnologySEGMENTATIONShorelineTechnologyUAVValidationWATER INDEX NDWIWAVE RUN-UPSchool of Life and Environmental SciencesFaculty of Science Engineering and Built EnvironmentGeomatic Engineering not elsewhere classifiedPhysical Geography and Environmental Geoscience not elsewhere classified
Licence
Exports
RefWorks
BibTeX
Ref. manager
Endnote
DataCite
NLM
DC