lawrence-communicationof-2014.pdf (635.99 kB)
Communication of scientific uncertainty: International case studies on the development of folate and vitamin D Dietary Reference Values
journal contribution
posted on 2014-08-29, 00:00 authored by K A Brown, L De Wit, L Timotijevic, A M Sonne, L Lähteenmäki, N Brito Garcia, M Jeruszka-Bielak, E Sicińska, A N Moore, Mark LawrenceMark Lawrence, M M RaatsObjective Transparent evidence-based decision making has been promoted worldwide to engender trust in science and policy making. Yet, little attention has been given to transparency implementation. The degree of transparency (focused on how uncertain evidence was handled) during the development of folate and vitamin D Dietary Reference Values was explored in three a priori defined areas: (i) value request; (ii) evidence evaluation; and (iii) final values. Design Qualitative case studies (semi-structured interviews and desk research). A common protocol was used for data collection, interview thematic analysis and reporting. Results were coordinated via cross-case synthesis. Setting Australia and New Zealand, Netherlands, Nordic countries, Poland, Spain and UK. Subjects Twenty-one interviews were conducted in six case studies. Results Transparency of process was not universally observed across countries or areas of the recommendation setting process. Transparency practices were most commonly seen surrounding the request to develop reference values (e.g. access to risk manager/assessor problem formulation discussions) and evidence evaluation (e.g. disclosure of risk assessor data sourcing/evaluation protocols). Fewer transparency practices were observed to assist with handling uncertainty in the evidence base during the development of quantitative reference values. Conclusions Implementation of transparency policies may be limited by a lack of dedicated resources and best practice procedures, particularly to assist with the latter stages of reference value development. Challenges remain regarding the best practice for transparently communicating the influence of uncertain evidence on the final reference values. Resolving this issue may assist the evolution of nutrition risk assessment and better inform the recommendation setting process.
History
Journal
Public health nutritionVolume
18Issue
8Pagination
1378 - 1388Publisher
Cambridge University PressLocation
Cambridge, EngPublisher DOI
ISSN
1368-9800eISSN
1475-2727Language
englishPublication classification
C Journal article; C1 Refereed article in a scholarly journalCopyright notice
2014, Cambridge University PressUsage metrics
Categories
No categories selectedKeywords
Licence
Exports
RefWorks
BibTeX
Ref. manager
Endnote
DataCite
NLM
DC