Deakin University
Browse

File(s) under permanent embargo

Derrida, friendship and the transcendental priority of the ‘untimely’

journal contribution
posted on 2010-07-01, 00:00 authored by Jack ReynoldsJack Reynolds
Derrida, friendship and the transcendental priority of the ‘untimely’

History

Journal

Philosophy & social criticism

Volume

36

Issue

6

Pagination

663 - 676

Publisher

Sage Publications Ltd.

Location

London, England

ISSN

0191-4537

eISSN

1461-734X

Language

eng

Notes

This article examines Derrida’s insistence on the contretemps that breaks open time, paying particular attention to Politics of Friendship and the way in which this book envisages the ‘untimely’ as both interrupting, and making possible, friendship. Although I suggest that Derrida’s temporal deconstruction of the Aristotelian distinction between utility and ‘perfect’ friendships is convincing, I also argue that Derrida’s own account of friendship is itself touched by time, in the peculiar sense of ‘touched’ that connotes affected and wounded. Derrida’s work instantiates what Husserl might call a transcendental pathology, in that it intermittently instantiates an ethics of non-presentist time (the time which is also the transcendental condition for the event of friendship), and, by contrast, disparages the significance of what we might call an ethics of phronesis, a ‘lived’ friendship of ‘omni-temporal’ dispositions, and embodied and habitual patterns. I end this article by proposing a dialectic between the disjunctive and conjunctive aspects of time that does not accord any kind of a priori privilege to the one over the other.

Publication classification

C1.1 Refereed article in a scholarly journal

Copyright notice

2010, Sage Publications