File(s) under permanent embargo

Metaphysics - low in price, high in value: a critique of global expressivism

journal contribution
posted on 01.01.2018, 00:00 authored by Cathy LeggCathy Legg, P Giladi
Pragmatism’s heartening recent revival (spearheaded by Richard Rorty’s bold inter-vention into analytic philosophy Philoso-phy and the Mirror of Nature) has coalesced into a distinctive philosophical movement frequently referred to as ‘neopragmatism’. This movement interprets the very meaning of pragmatism as rejection of metaphysical commitments: our words do not primarily serve to represent non-linguistic entities, but are tools to achieve a range of human purposes. A particularly thorough and consistent version of this position is Huw Price’s global expressivism. We here critically appraise Price’s under-standing of a commitment to pragmatism as a rejection of metaphysics, and argue that such rejection is not as easy or desir-able as Price claims. First we argue that Price’s global expressivism itself draws on significant metaphysical assumptions (a ‘word-world’ dualism, and a nominalism concerning the meaning of general terms). Then we seek to resolve neopragmatist anx-ieties about metaphysics by arguing that metaphysics is indispensable for pragmatist philosophizing insofar as it seeks ways for human beings to realise themselves through practices of understanding reality and their place in it. If, as we argue, metaphysics consists in a maximally general inquiry into the nature and structure of reality, to try to block it seems a puzzling exercise in epis-temic self-harm.

History

Journal

Transactions of the Charles S. Peirce Society

Volume

54

Issue

1

Season

Winter

Pagination

64 - 83

Publisher

Indiana University Press

Location

Bloomington, Ind.

ISSN

0009-1774

Language

eng

Publication classification

C1 Refereed article in a scholarly journal

Copyright notice

2018, Charles S. Peirce Society