Deakin University
Browse

File(s) not publicly available

The people shall be judge: Reflective judgment and constituent power in Kant's philosophy of law

journal contribution
posted on 2011-12-01, 00:00 authored by Miguel VatterMiguel Vatter
This essay offers an interpretation of Kant’s republicanism in light of the problem of political judgment. Kant is sometimes thought to base his conception of law on an idea of sovereignty drawn from Hobbes and Rousseau, which would leave little room for popular contestation of the state. In this essay, I reconstruct Kant’s account of the rule of law by bringing out the importance of his theory of judgment. I argue that for Kant the civil condition is ultimately characterized by a contest between the judgment of the sovereign and the judgment of the people, which corresponds to the determinative and reflective employments of political judgment, respectively. On this view, popular sovereignty is ultimately located in the people’s power to judge politically and contest publicly the state.

History

Journal

Political Theory

Volume

39

Article number

6

Pagination

749-776

ISSN

0090-5917

eISSN

1552-7476

Language

English

Publication classification

C1.1 Refereed article in a scholarly journal

Issue

6

Publisher

SAGE PUBLICATIONS INC